Court orders FG to pay Delta $1.638bn derivative arrears
A Federal High Court, Abuja, on Monday, ordered the Federal Government to pay 1.638 billion dollars to Delta Government being 13 per cent derivative sum due as arrears of revenue payable to the oil-rich state.
Justice Donatus Okorowo, while delivering the judgment, held that being a suit instituted to recover revenue accruing to the state government, it qualified for the undefended list.
Okorowo ruled that the development made the court to declare the plaintiff’s case as “unchallenged.”
The News Agency of Nigeria (NAN) reports that while the Attorney-General of Delta is the plaintiff, the Attorney-General of the Federation (AGF) is the sole defendant in the suit.
The plaintiff, in the suit marked: FHC/ABJ/CS/660/2012 and filed on July 12 by his counsel, Ken Njemanze, SAN, urged the court to compel the AGF to pay five per cent of 50 billion dollars recovered as additional revenue accrued to the Nigerian government.
Justice Okorowo dismissed the AGF’s preliminary objections, challenging the court’s jurisdiction to entertain the suit as well as the mode in which the case was instituted as ‘undefended list.’
NAN reports that Okorowo had, in an ex-parte application on July 22, ruled that the “plaintiff’s writ of summons be marked and placed on the undefended list.”
The judge, therefore, granted all the reliefs of the Delta government.
“The suit succeeds on its merit and all the reliefs sought by plaintiff are granted,” he ruled.
NAN reports that Delta government, through its Attorney-General, had in an affidavit setting forth the grounds upon which its claim was based, urged the court to “direct the defendant (AGF) to pay the sum of $ 1,638,396,277.00 (One billion, six hundred and thirty-eight million, three hundred and ninety-six thousand, two hundred and seventy-seven United States dollars) being the 13 per cent derivative sum due as arrears of revenue payable to Delta as assessed.
“A consequential order of this court compelling the defendant to net off and pay five per cent of the said sum as per clause 3.0(v) of the defendant’s letter of engagement dated 12 April, 2018 and clause 3.0(v) the defendant’s further letter of engagement dated Nov. 19, 2018, pursuant to clause lll(d) of the terms of settlement made the (consent) judgment by the Supreme Court.
“10 per cent post judgment interest at court rate on the said $ 1,638,396,277.00 (One billion, six hundred and thirty-eight million, three hundred and ninety-six thousand, two hundred and seventy-seven United States dollars) to the plaintiff until final liquidation thereof.”
While urging the court to discountenance the AGF’s claim that it was not a party to the suit lodged by the Akwa-Ibom, Bayelsa and Rivers governments, the plaintiff said,”The suit described above was instituted in the Supreme Court for the enforcement of the general of the littoral states (of which Delta is one.)
It added, “The plaintiff has a pecuniary interest in the said suit and its outcome affects her rights and or liabilities.”
However, in an affidavit disclosing defence on merit by Mr Tbomas Etah, a staff at the Federal Ministry of Justice, Abuja, the AGF had argued that Delta was not a party in the terms of settlement in the suit between the Akwa-Ibom, Bayelsa and Rivers State governments delivered by the Supreme Court.
He further contended that “it will not serve the interest of justice to grant the plaintiff’s claim against the defendant without full hearing.
“That the terms of settlement in question have been entered as judgement of the court between the parties before the court.”
In the defendant’s notice of preliminary objection dated Sept. 22, the lawyer submitted that the jurisdiction of the Federal High Court under Section 251 of the Constitution did not include adjudication between a state and the federation.
“The subject matter of this suit is a dispute between the Delta as a state and the federation.
“That the subject matter relates to the recovery of revenue accruing to the federation account, the beneficiaries of which are the federation and the states of the federation.
“That the subject matter of this suit is not to be commenced by way of undefended list,” the AGF lawyer had argued, urging the court to dismiss the suit.
But Justice Okorowo granted the reliefssoyght by the plaintiff.
“Judgment is hereby entered on the claims of the plaintiff in this case. This is the order of this court,” he declared.
It would be recalled that the Federal High Court, Abuja had, in June, gave a similar ordered that the Federal Government should pay 951 million dollars to the Bayelsa Government as 13 per cent derivative sum due as arrears of revenue.
Also, the court ordered the Federal Government to pay the sum of 3.3 billion dollars to Rivers and Akwa Ibom governments, being their revenue share from crude oil sales.
The Akwa Ibom, Bayelsa and Rivers governments had sued the AGF at the Supreme Court, demanding an upward adjustment of the shares of revenues accruing to the Nigerian government whenever the price of crude oil exceeds 20 dollars per barrel.
